Talk:What if Barney and Friends Season 4-present was made like Musical Scrapbook (SuperMalechi's version)/@comment-3300142-20140804151322/@comment-3300142-20140804153116

Most people would choose S14 because of its reruns of S10-11, to me that's no surprise and S14 is a bad season. To me S4 is the worst in my books. It's very overrated, it has some okay episodes like 'Good Day, Good Night' but there are some stories that are terrible and unrealistic for one example is 'Good Clean Fun', why on earth would BJ sneeze a lot without getting sick? Why would there be a bathtub in school?! And finally, why did BJ sneeze a lot in tissues,without it getting dirty? No reason or logic whatsoever. Another episode is 'Let's Build Together', why would BJ make messes without getting hurt? Why would Scooter get hit by pieces of broken things with no pain? Again no reason or logic. 'We've Got Rhythm', why would a loud drumming sound make the Barney doll fall? No reason whatsoever it's just not real. 'Tremendous Trees', why would Barney stand on a rolling skateboard after he came to life? No reason, 'Cranky Bugs', I find that a good episode though, why was Cranky there in the first place? No reason. Barney and Friends, is a show that are suppose to be about simple adventures about singing songs with a few surprises along the way, not all of the over troubles. Plus when you watch 'Let's Build Together', that is where the don't know how side of BJ started, in my opinion, he's suppose to be a really splendid character. There are good episodes like 'Easy Breezy Day' and 'Going on a Bear Hunt' but unfortunetly they were overshadowed by the terribleness of this season. Plus there was, at the time, one-off characters too for the sake of merchandising. Pennies in My Pocket would be considered as one-off's at the time. Jingle at the Window is another one, even though it was made to be one-off's and The Adventure Song, no backtime, no reason, just for toys and the Bakery set, probably the most overrated one-off in my opinion, originally suppose to be a different set, but they just reused the pizza set and modified it and claim him as a 'new location', as a kid my older brother and I knew it was the pizza place's basis and we're confused by it, though my older brother outgrew Barney years before the fourth season though. S4 is the most overrated season in the classic series, hands down, its episodes and costumes/voices are over the top, horrible for the younger audience today and terrible.